All I Want For Christmas Is: Pretty Plate’s Reindeer Chow

There is one thing that should definitely be on your list this year and it is this Pretty Plate Reindeer Chow. This chocolate, peanut butter, butter ball, sugar cookie mix is a dream come true. I am pretty sure that if you were to look up the word “addictive“ in the dictionary this Pretty Plate Reindeer Chow would be apart of the definition. Once you try it, it will be the only treat you will want for Christmas. It is the perfect snack for yourself or gift to others.

If you don‘t want to or don’t have time to make homemade Christmas cookies this year, wash all of those worries away because this recipe is for you! All you need to do is just make sure to add this to your list and be prepared to possibly make a batch or two, or even three of this Pretty Plate Reindeer Chow. And I say an extra two or three batches because you need one for yourself, one for Santa and one for the reindeers of course! This is an easy recipe and it doesn’t involve Christmas cookies, however, it does taste like a mix of them. I can guarantee that kids and adults of all ages will love this!

Growing up I ate puppy chow aka muddy buddies more than I would like to admit. I was an active gymnast and in between practices and competitions sometimes I would catch myself snacking on it. It was always one of those things that Gymnastics Mom’s brought as a small little treat especially on those Pasta Party nights. And now looking back, I know why they always had it on hand: it is easy to make and extremely delicious.

While, I can’t call puppy chow my own recipe as this has been a staple that everyone has known and grown to love over the years (kudos to the actual person who created this), I did create this Reindeer chow with a few of my favorite things that I think all of you will love! I wanted to incorporate a mix of one of everyone’s favorite staple (puppy chow) with sugar cookie flavors and savory salty buttery flavors as well. This way you get a little bit of everything and mixing and matching is so fun!

What makes this so good? Great question! Well let’s start by talking about how the warm chocolatey peanut buttery mixture seeps into every single chex cereal piece and then, how the powdered sugar somehow makes it way through every nook and cranny as well, so every puppy chow piece gets perfectly coated. Plus, on top of all of that goodness, you mix in: squishy mini marshmallows, crispy sugar cookie M&M’s, buttery salty pretzel balls, soft funfetti chips, crunchy coconut macaroon almonds and tender dark chocolate raisinets.

I also have to admit that the larger puppy chow chunks that get stuck together like glue by too much chocolatey peanut buttery powdery sugar goodness are like gold. I intentionally pick through the mix to claim those before they are gone. I can’t be the only one that does this, can I!?

So, with all of this being said, make your list and check it twice, you‘re going to want to make sure you have all these ingredients by Christmas night becuase Santa Clause is coming to town! Tag @prettyplatebymichelle or #prettyplatebymichelle on instagram if you make this. I would love to see all of your fun festive holiday activities!

Serves 10+, INGREDIENTS: To Make

1 12 oz. box of rice chex

2 bags of ghridell’s dark chocolate wafers

1 cup smooth peanut butter

3-4 cups powdered sugar

Jet puffed mini marshmallows

Snyder’s butter round pretzel balls


Toll house funfetti chips

M&M sugar cookie m&m’s

Coconut macaroon almonds

To Assemble and Mix Together:

5 cups puppy chow (you will have extra puppy chow left over)

1 8 oz bag raisinets

1 7.4 oz bag of sugar cookie m&m’s

1 10 oz tin coconut Macaroon almonds (from mariano’s In the snack shelf/bar section next to the product) You can also use another type of almond if you would like or you can omit

1 cup mini marshmallows

1 9 oz bag tollhouse funfetti chips

2 cup Snyder’s pretzel round balls (from mariano’s)


  1. Pour your box of chex mix in a large bowl and set aside.

  2. Heat a pot over medium heat, add your chocolate and melt. Once melted add your peanut butter. Mix well until smooth. When mixed, remove from heat. Let it cool for 1 minute.

  3. Pour your chocolate peanut butter mixture over your chex cereal. Mix well. Make sure all pieces are full coated.

  4. Once they are coated with the chocolate peanut butter mixture, pour your powdered sugar over and mix well again. I would start by adding 2 cups and mixing. Add more cups in as needed until they are all fully coated and white.

  5. Once chocolate and powdered sugar has settled on the chex cereal. Measure out 5 cup of puppy chow and place in a large bowl. Add: 1 8 oz bag raisinets, 1 7.4 oz bag of sugar cookie m&m’s, 1 10 oz tin coconut Macaroon almonds, 1 cup marshmallows, 1 9 oz bag funfetti chips and 2 cup pretzel round balls.

  6. Using your hands or a spoon and a fork, mix the reinder chow until everything is well mixed.

  7. Serve immediately and store in an air tight container when not consuming.

  8. ENJOY!


  1. Crate and Barrel Large White Bowl with Wood Lid

  2. Ball Mason Jars

  3. Mixing Bowls Set

  4. Matte Black Measuring Cup Set

35 views0 comments

Sign up to get my latest recipes and updates

  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Copyright © 2021 All Rights Reserved | Pretty Plate LLC